Hay and Forage Exchange

Straw vs Hay for Bedding and Feed

Straw is the stalks left after grain harvest, while hay is a forage crop cut for feed. They differ in nutrition, absorbency, cost and what they are best used for.

Why it matters

Buying one when you needed the other wastes money or hurts animals. Straw makes cheaper, drier bedding but is poor feed, while hay is better nutrition but costs more as a bedding. Knowing the difference first saves both.

Step by step

  1. List the job: bedding, emergency roughage, or part of a ration, since each calls for a different material and quality.
  2. Compare nutrition: hay carries more protein and energy, while straw is low and mostly fiber, suitable as filler only.
  3. Compare bedding performance: straw is usually bright and absorbent and dries fast, while hay can mat and mold when damp.
  4. Check for dust, mold and weeds in either one, especially for horses and animals with breathing problems.
  5. Calculate cost per stall per day using the bale weight, price and your daily usage, then compare them.

What good looks like

A good choice matches the job: straw for bedding where the animals have other feed, hay for nutrition. You know the daily cost of each and have checked both for mold and dust.

Worked example

Illustrative: a 40 pound straw bale at $5 is $0.125 per pound, so 8 pounds per stall daily costs $1.00. A 50 pound hay bale at $7 is $0.14 per pound, so 12 pounds costs $1.68. For 10 stalls over 30 days, straw costs $300 and hay $504. The gap is $204 over the month (504 minus 300). All figures are made up.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Feeding straw as the main forage to animals with high nutrient needs.
  • Using moldy hay or straw as bedding because it is cheap.
  • Comparing price per bale without also comparing the weight of each bale.
  • Ignoring dust, which can irritate animal and human lungs in closed barns.

Safety, legal and compliance notes

Some animals can choke or colic if fed unsuitable roughage. Ask your veterinarian before changing the forage or bedding for horses, young stock or animals with health problems.

What to record

Keep a dated hay file: field and cutting, harvest and baling dates, bale counts and weights, moisture at baling, forage test results, storage location, sales or purchase prices and the animals fed. Good records let you compare cuttings, plan winter feed and settle disputes with buyers.

When to ask for help

Weight, moisture, weed-free certification, hauling and sales tax rules vary by state. Talk with your extension forage specialist, a forage testing lab, your state department of agriculture and your insurance agent before you buy, sell, store or haul large amounts of hay. The state directory lists agencies and resources in every state.

Frequently asked questions

Can animals eat straw?

Some can use it as filler, but nutrition is low. Ask your veterinarian or nutritionist before relying on straw for any part of a ration.

Which absorbs more moisture?

Straw is usually bright, hollow and absorbent, so it holds more per pound than most hay. Both need regular changing to stay clean.

Is wheat straw the same as oat straw?

They differ in softness, nutrition and dustiness. Pick the type that suits your animals and compare samples before buying a large lot.

Related guides

More from the network

Farm news, humor and ranch life at farm.FM.