Hay and Forage Exchange

Hay Types and Uses Compared

Common hay types include alfalfa, clover, grass, small grain and mixed stands. They differ in protein, energy, fiber, yield, price and which animals they suit, so the right choice depends on the job.

Why it matters

The cheapest bale per ton is rarely the cheapest feed. Comparing cost per pound of the nutrient you need, such as protein, shows which type earns its price for your animals and which only looks cheap on the invoice.

Step by step

  1. List what your animals need most: protein for growth and lactation, fiber for gut health, or simple bulk for maintenance.
  2. Gather typical lab values for each hay type on offer, using real tests for the lots you are considering.
  3. Compute cost per pound of crude protein: price per ton divided by pounds of protein in a ton.
  4. Weigh trade-offs such as dust, mold risk, palatability, leaf loss and stems your animals will refuse.
  5. Choose one type, or blend two, and set a plan for storing each separately.

What good looks like

A good choice meets the animals' needs at the lowest total cost, with little refusal and waste. The record shows tested values, cost per nutrient and the reason you picked each type.

Worked example

Illustrative numbers: alfalfa at 200 dollars per ton and 18 percent protein holds 360 lb of protein per ton, so protein costs 0.56 dollars per lb. Grass hay at 120 dollars per ton and 10 percent protein holds 200 lb, costing 0.60 dollars per lb. For 4 lb of protein daily, that is 2.24 dollars versus 2.40. The pricier hay is cheaper protein.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Comparing price per bale instead of price per ton or per nutrient.
  • Buying rich legume hay for animals that only need maintenance feed.
  • Assuming every grass hay is low quality regardless of cutting date.
  • Ignoring waste, which is higher with coarse stemmy hay of any type.

Safety, legal and compliance notes

Some hay types can cause problems for certain animals, such as bloat, nitrate or toxic weeds. Ask a veterinarian or extension forage specialist before changing feed for sensitive or high-value animals.

What to record

Keep a dated hay file: field and cutting, harvest and baling dates, bale counts and weights, moisture at baling, forage test results, storage location, sales or purchase prices and the animals fed. Good records let you compare cuttings, plan winter feed and settle disputes with buyers.

When to ask for help

Weight, moisture, weed-free certification, hauling and sales tax rules vary by state. Talk with your extension forage specialist, a forage testing lab, your state department of agriculture and your insurance agent before you buy, sell, store or haul large amounts of hay. The state directory lists agencies and resources in every state.

Frequently asked questions

Which hay has the most protein?

Legume hays such as alfalfa and clover usually test highest in protein. Actual values depend on maturity at cutting, so rely on a lab test for each lot.

Is mixed hay a good compromise?

Often yes. A legume and grass mix can balance protein and fiber, but the ratio varies by field, so test it rather than assume.

Can one hay type suit every animal?

Rarely. Growing and lactating animals need richer feed than idle adults. Matching hay to each group saves money and prevents both underfeeding and waste.

Related guides

More from the network

Farm news, humor and ranch life at farm.FM.