Hay and Forage Exchange

Legume vs Grass Hay

Legume hays such as alfalfa and clover are high in protein and calcium. Grass hays are higher in fiber and lower in protein. Each has strengths, weaknesses and best uses for different animals.

Why it matters

Many feeding mistakes come from treating legume and grass hay as interchangeable. Legumes can overfeed protein to idle animals, while grass alone can leave growing or lactating animals short on protein and energy, raising both cost and risk.

Step by step

  1. Test both hays and record protein, fiber and moisture, since book averages can miss your fields by a wide margin.
  2. Compare animal needs with each result and note where grass alone falls short or legume alone overshoots.
  3. Calculate a blend by weight so the mix protein lands near what the group needs.
  4. Watch intake and manure for a week after changing the blend, and adjust if animals sort or refuse.
  5. Store the two hays separately and label stacks, so each feeding group gets the planned ratio.

What good looks like

A good blend meets protein and energy targets without waste, and animals eat it evenly. Test results back up the ratio, and the records show it was adjusted when a new lot arrived.

Worked example

Illustrative blend: 20 lb of alfalfa at 18 percent protein carries 3.6 lb of protein. Add 10 lb of grass hay at 9 percent, carrying 0.9 lb. Together that is 4.5 lb of protein in 30 lb of hay, a 15 percent mix, assuming equal moisture. Ten cows eating 30 lb each use 300 lb daily: 200 lb alfalfa and 100 lb grass.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Feeding straight legume hay to animals that only need maintenance.
  • Assuming grass hay is always poor when it was cut early.
  • Mixing hays without weighing, so the actual ratio drifts every feeding.
  • Skipping a transition period when switching types, which can upset digestion.

Safety, legal and compliance notes

Rich legume feed can cause bloat or digestive upset in some animals if introduced too fast. Consult a veterinarian or livestock nutritionist about transition plans and mineral balance for your species.

What to record

Keep a dated hay file: field and cutting, harvest and baling dates, bale counts and weights, moisture at baling, forage test results, storage location, sales or purchase prices and the animals fed. Good records let you compare cuttings, plan winter feed and settle disputes with buyers.

When to ask for help

Weight, moisture, weed-free certification, hauling and sales tax rules vary by state. Talk with your extension forage specialist, a forage testing lab, your state department of agriculture and your insurance agent before you buy, sell, store or haul large amounts of hay. The state directory lists agencies and resources in every state.

Frequently asked questions

Is alfalfa better than grass hay?

Not always. Alfalfa is richer in protein, but that is wasted on animals with low needs. Grass hay often fits maintenance feeding at a lower cost.

How do I blend hays without a mixer?

Feed set weights of each hay at every feeding, using a scale or counted bales of known weight, so the ratio stays steady.

Why do legume hays cost more?

They usually test higher in protein and yield less per cutting in many stands, and buyers pay for the nutrients. Compare price per pound of protein instead.

Related guides

More from the network

Farm news, humor and ranch life at farm.FM.