Hay and Forage Exchange

Judging Hay by Sight and Smell

Sight, smell and touch cannot replace a lab test, but they spot problems fast. A quick inspection helps you decide which lots deserve testing and which to reject at once.

Why it matters

Visual checks catch mold, dust, weeds and heat damage that a lab report may not show. A consistent scoring method keeps your buying decisions fair rather than driven by a sales pitch or a hunch.

Step by step

  1. Open several bales and look at color, leaf share and stem thickness, noting any bleached or dark patches.
  2. Smell the interior, since a sweet fresh scent is good, while musty, sour or burnt smells are warning signs.
  3. Squeeze a handful and feel for dampness, heat or dustiness, and shake it to see how many leaves fall.
  4. Search for weeds, trash, sticks, dead animals or other foreign matter by pulling bales apart.
  5. Score each factor from zero to three, total the scores, and send promising lots for a lab test.

What good looks like

A good score shows a green, leafy, clean, sweet smelling lot with fine stems. A similar score from two different people shows the method is consistent and repeatable across stacks and seasons.

Worked example

Illustrative scoring out of 15: color 2, leaf 3, foreign matter 2, smell 3, stems 1. The total is 2 plus 3 plus 2 plus 3 plus 1, which is 11 out of 15, or about 73 percent. A rule of testing any lot above 10 would send this one to the lab, while a lot scoring 7 would be rejected.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Judging by outer bale color only, since weathered surfaces mislead.
  • Skipping the smell check on bales from the middle of the stack.
  • Treating a good look as proof of high protein or energy.
  • Handling dusty or moldy hay without a mask or ventilation.

Safety, legal and compliance notes

Moldy and dusty hay can irritate lungs and harm animals. Wear a respirator when handling suspect bales, and ask a veterinarian or extension specialist about any hay with heavy mold or toxic weeds.

What to record

Keep a dated hay file: field and cutting, harvest and baling dates, bale counts and weights, moisture at baling, forage test results, storage location, sales or purchase prices and the animals fed. Good records let you compare cuttings, plan winter feed and settle disputes with buyers.

When to ask for help

Weight, moisture, weed-free certification, hauling and sales tax rules vary by state. Talk with your extension forage specialist, a forage testing lab, your state department of agriculture and your insurance agent before you buy, sell, store or haul large amounts of hay. The state directory lists agencies and resources in every state.

Frequently asked questions

Can smell tell me protein?

No. Smell shows freshness or spoilage but not nutrient content. Only a lab test can tell you protein, fiber and energy values for sure.

Does green color mean good hay?

Often it means little sun bleaching, but color is only one sign. Check leaves, stems, smell and weeds, then test the lot.

What if bales look good outside but bad inside?

Reject or discount the lot and test samples from the inside. Surface looks can hide mold, heating damage or trash within the bale.

Related guides

More from the network

Farm news, humor and ranch life at farm.FM.