Hay and Forage Exchange

Cost Per Pound of Nutrient Worksheet

Hay priced per ton hides how much nutrition you actually get. This worksheet converts price into cost per pound of protein and energy, so different hays compare fairly side by side.

Why it matters

A cheap ton of low quality hay may force you to buy extra feed to fill the gap. Pricing the nutrients you need often shows that the higher priced hay is the better value for one need.

Step by step

  1. Write each hay's price per ton and its as-fed protein and energy percent from the lab report.
  2. Compute pounds of protein per ton: multiply 2,000 by the protein percent as a decimal, and repeat for energy.
  3. Divide price per ton by pounds of protein, then by pounds of energy, giving cost per pound of each.
  4. Rank the hays for the nutrient your animals need most, since lactating cows and idle horses need different things.
  5. Add delivery cost per ton to each price before you compute, so the comparison covers the same landed cost.

What good looks like

A good worksheet shows each hay as a cost per pound of protein and energy, makes the trade-offs visible, and picks a winner for your animals' actual needs rather than for the lowest ton price.

Worked example

Illustrative: Hay A costs $180 per ton with 16 percent protein and 62 percent energy. Hay B costs $150 with 11 percent and 55 percent. A gives 320 pounds protein and 1,240 energy: $0.56 and $0.145 per pound. B gives 220 and 1,100: $0.68 and $0.136. B wins on energy, A on protein. Buy A if protein is short and B if energy is short, using these made-up figures.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Comparing hay on price per ton alone without looking at lab values.
  • Mixing dry matter numbers for one hay with as-fed numbers for another.
  • Leaving out freight, which can erase the price gap between two hays.
  • Chasing high protein when your animals actually need energy, or the reverse.

Safety, legal and compliance notes

Nutrient needs vary by species, age and production stage. Ask a veterinarian or livestock nutritionist to confirm what your animals need before changing a ration.

What to record

Keep a dated hay file: field and cutting, harvest and baling dates, bale counts and weights, moisture at baling, forage test results, storage location, sales or purchase prices and the animals fed. Good records let you compare cuttings, plan winter feed and settle disputes with buyers.

When to ask for help

Weight, moisture, weed-free certification, hauling and sales tax rules vary by state. Talk with your extension forage specialist, a forage testing lab, your state department of agriculture and your insurance agent before you buy, sell, store or haul large amounts of hay. The state directory lists agencies and resources in every state.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference as-fed and dry matter?

As-fed includes the water in the hay. Dry matter removes it. Use one basis for every hay you compare, or your result will mislead.

Which nutrient should I price first?

Start with the one limiting your animals, often energy for growing or lactating stock and protein for thin cattle on low quality forage.

Should I include waste in the worksheet?

Yes, if you can estimate it. Divide the cost by the usable fraction, since hay that gets trampled or refused is still paid for.

Related guides

More from the network

Farm news, humor and ranch life at farm.FM.